Today I have a review on some eye makeup remover by Alba Botanica.
It is the Advanced Even Natural Sea Elements eye makeup remover (4oz). I found this in the Target clearance section, and the clearance price on this was cheaper than the regular price of the eye makeup remover I normally buy. I saw that the regular price of this was somewhere near $9.00, which is no where near what I'd spend on eye makeup remover, so I purchased it. I read really good reviews about it online when I got home and was anxious to try it out.
Here's a quirky little tidbit about me: I LOVE to read labels of products. Sometimes I even make my husband read them to me if I just bought something at a store and I'm the one driving home. Weird I know, but anywho. Upon reading the label of this eye makeup remover, it claims to be non-greasy, as well as tough on waterproof makeup ("with one swipe" I believe it says). I was excited to see that it was not tested on animals (YAY!) and also made with 100% vegetable ingredients. It does make it a point to advise the consumer to shake it before each use.
I have been using it for more than a month now and really liked it... at first. It did a great job. I did however find it to be very greasy (contrary to what the label says), which is okay with me. Once I take my makeup off at the end of the day, I hop in the shower anyway, so no big deal. Here is my main beef with this product: Just last week I started using a new *waterproof* mascara and this eye makeup remover barely does a thing as far as removing it. In order to get it moderately off, I have to use multiple cotton squares and continuously add more and more remover and my lashes are still full of mascara. (Note: I do shake it before each use as directed). I feel like it isn't good to have to rub my eyes that much each night just to use this product. I don't know if this is a bi-layer product like some other removers that separate and that's why you have to shake it, but this does not do the job. One of the bi-layer removers I refer to is Lancome Bi-Facil eye makeup remover. I have a little travel size bottle of that and tried that after the Alba Botanica didn't work. The Lancome was easy breezy, so I have stopped using the Alba Botanica and switched to the Lancome. (Note: I received the Lancome Bi-Facil as part of a gift and it is about $27 for the full size bottle, which is even more than I'm willing to pay. I have found that Neutrogena's Oil-Free makeup remover is comparable and a lot more affordable).
I am certainly glad I did not pay full price for this eye makeup remover. While I did like it at first when I wasn't using waterproof mascara, now that I am, it is pretty much useless to me. I still like it's "green" properties, but I since the product doesn't serve its purpose, it's not enough for me to give it a positive review. Sorry y'all.
To see my YouTube video review of this product, please click here.